firai wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2020 4:12 am
It seems alkaline batteries leaking when shorted or after deep discharge is related to the chemistry. NiMH shouldn't leak, and I haven't had a problem with Eneloops leaking at all.
Here you are confusing two things, the structure and the electrochemical reaction of a battery at the end of its service life have nothing to do with each other. NiMH batteries are still one of the most reliable products in this sector today, they stay fresh for years even when not in use. But that doesn't mean that you can simply forget it in a device (including chargers) for a whole decade and then get upset about possible damage in the end. This is clearly the fault of the user and not the type of battery.
firai wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2020 4:12 am
Sorry for continuing this off-topic discussion, but the "Made in China" Eneloops are generally considered to have inferior discharge curves and characteristics than the "Made in Japan" ones. Search your favourite search engine for this topic, and a number of discussions about the comparison (including community-provided test data) will come up.
Such discussions should not be taken too seriously, generalizations are often made without real facts, especially not with "community-provided test data". People who are unable or unwilling to adequately document their test methods should rather hold back with their flimsy arguments, regardless of whether they are simple users or experts. Such colourful diagrams have never convinced me!
firai wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2020 4:12 am
As you said, given enough quality control, "Made in China" can be just as good (or even better) as any other "Made in XXX". However, in this particular case, the end product does not appear to be the same. Whether this is a conscious decision by Panasonic to provide a lower cost/lower spec. product in certain markets is not certain.
Look, if Panasonic sees that the quality cannot be continuously maintained at certain locations, then the manufacturer will certainly draw the necessary conclusions. You can trust that Panasonic's management is professional enough to respond to such a thing with appropriate measures. Like many other companies, Panasonic has to struggle with the illegal activities of pirates and their counterfeits, so I wouldn't be surprised if a few users come to the wrong conclusions afterwards and generally dismiss eneloop as a bad product, no matter where it came from. In the end, it is always up to the customer whether or not to accept a registered branded product "Made in China".
